| SINTA |
Peer Review Process
Peer Review Process
IQ (Ilmu Al-Qur’an): Jurnal Pendidikan Islam
1. Peer Review Policy
IQ (Ilmu Al-Qur’an): Jurnal Pendidikan Islam is committed to maintaining high standards of academic quality, originality, and integrity through a rigorous and impartial peer-review process.
All research articles submitted to the journal are subject to editorial screening and, if considered suitable, independent peer review by qualified experts in the relevant fields of Islamic education and related disciplines.
The peer-review process aims to evaluate the originality, scholarly contribution, theoretical foundation, methodological rigor, clarity of presentation, and relevance of each manuscript to the journal's focus and scope.
Editorial decisions are made independently and are based on scholarly merit, reviewers' recommendations, and the journal's publication standards.
2. Type of Peer Review
The journal adopts a double-anonymous peer-review system, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the review process.
Authors must remove identifying information from the main manuscript file, including names, institutional affiliations, acknowledgments, and other details that could directly reveal their identities.
Author information must be provided separately through the journal's online submission system or in a separate title page, as instructed by the editorial office.
Reviewers are expected to avoid attempting to identify the authors and to maintain the confidentiality of the review process.
3. Stages of the Peer-Review Process
The peer-review process consists of the following stages.
Stage 1: Manuscript Submission
Authors submit their manuscripts through the journal's official Open Journal Systems (OJS) platform.
The submission must comply with the Author Guidelines and include the required manuscript components, metadata, and supporting documents.
Stage 2: Initial Editorial Screening
The editorial team conducts an initial assessment to determine whether the manuscript:
-
Falls within the journal's focus and scope.
-
Demonstrates sufficient originality and academic relevance.
-
Meets the basic requirements of scholarly writing and manuscript preparation.
-
Complies with the journal's publication ethics and submission policies.
-
Provides an appropriate research design or analytical framework for its stated objectives.
Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements may be rejected at this stage or returned to the authors for preliminary revision.
Stage 3: Plagiarism and Ethical Screening
Submitted manuscripts may be screened using plagiarism-detection software or other appropriate methods.
The editorial team evaluates any identified similarities in context and may examine relevant ethical declarations, permissions, or supporting documentation when necessary.
Manuscripts suspected of plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, or other serious ethical violations may be suspended from further processing pending clarification or investigation.
Stage 4: Reviewer Assignment
Manuscripts that pass the initial screening are assigned to qualified reviewers with relevant academic expertise.
The journal normally seeks evaluations from at least two independent reviewers for each manuscript undergoing external peer review.
Reviewers are selected based on their subject expertise, research experience, academic qualifications, and ability to provide objective assessments.
The editorial team seeks to avoid conflicts of interest when selecting reviewers.
Stage 5: Peer Review
Reviewers evaluate manuscripts according to relevant academic criteria, including:
-
Originality and novelty of the research.
-
Relevance to the journal's focus and scope.
-
Clarity of the research problem and objectives.
-
Adequacy of the theoretical framework and literature review.
-
Appropriateness and rigor of the research methodology.
-
Accuracy and clarity of data presentation and analysis.
-
Quality of the discussion and interpretation of findings.
-
Contribution to Islamic educational theory, policy, or practice.
-
Quality of academic writing, organization, and referencing.
-
Compliance with research ethics and publication standards.
Reviewers provide constructive comments and recommendations to help editors determine the manuscript's suitability for publication.
Stage 6: Editorial Decision
Based on the reviewers' reports and the editor's independent assessment, the manuscript may receive one of the following decisions:
-
Accept: The manuscript is accepted for publication without substantive revision, subject to final editorial checks.
-
Minor Revision: The manuscript requires limited corrections or clarifications.
-
Major Revision: The manuscript requires substantial improvements before it can be reconsidered.
-
Reject: The manuscript does not meet the journal's requirements for publication.
A request for revision does not guarantee acceptance. Revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers or evaluated by the editor, depending on the nature of the revisions.
The final decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor.
Stage 7: Revision and Re-evaluation
Authors receiving a revision decision must submit a revised manuscript within the deadline specified by the editorial office.
Authors should also provide a point-by-point response explaining how each reviewer comment has been addressed. Where a suggestion is not adopted, the authors should provide a clear academic justification.
The editorial team may request further revisions or additional review if significant concerns remain unresolved.
Stage 8: Final Acceptance and Publication
Manuscripts that successfully complete the review and revision process undergo final editorial preparation, including copyediting, formatting, proofreading, and verification of publication metadata.
The corresponding author may be asked to review the proofs before publication.
Accepted manuscripts are scheduled for publication in the forthcoming available issue, subject to the journal's production schedule and editorial requirements.
4. Review Timeline
The journal seeks to process submissions efficiently while allowing reviewers sufficient time for careful scholarly evaluation.
The following timelines are recommended editorial targets rather than guaranteed deadlines:
| Process | Target duration |
|---|---|
| Initial editorial screening | 1–2 weeks |
| External peer review | 3–6 weeks |
| Author revision | 2–4 weeks for minor revisions; 4–8 weeks for major revisions |
| Final editorial decision after revision | 1–3 weeks |
| Copyediting and production | According to publication readiness |
Actual processing times may vary depending on reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, the extent of revisions required, and the responsiveness of authors.
Authors can monitor the status of their submissions through the OJS platform or contact the editorial office for relevant updates.
5. Responsibilities of Reviewers
Reviewers are expected to:
-
Provide objective, fair, and constructive assessments.
-
Maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts and review materials.
-
Disclose potential conflicts of interest before accepting an assignment.
-
Decline assignments when their impartiality may be compromised.
-
Identify relevant scholarly sources that have not been adequately cited.
-
Report suspected plagiarism, data manipulation, or other ethical concerns to the editor.
-
Avoid personal criticism and focus on the manuscript's scholarly content.
-
Submit their evaluations within the agreed timeframe.
Reviewers must not use unpublished information obtained through peer review for personal or professional advantage.
6. Responsibilities of Authors
Authors are expected to:
-
Submit original work that falls within the journal's scope.
-
Ensure the accuracy and integrity of their research and references.
-
Respond to reviewer comments professionally and substantively.
-
Revise their manuscripts within the specified timeframe.
-
Provide a clear response to each reviewer comment.
-
Disclose relevant conflicts of interest and funding sources.
-
Comply with the journal's authorship, plagiarism, research ethics, and AI policies.
-
Maintain the confidentiality of the review process where required.
Authors must not attempt to influence reviewers improperly or contact reviewers directly about confidential editorial matters.
7. Responsibilities of Editors
Editors are responsible for managing the peer-review process fairly, independently, and transparently.
They must:
-
Select appropriate and qualified reviewers.
-
Ensure that reviewer assignments are free from unmanaged conflicts of interest.
-
Maintain confidentiality throughout the review process.
-
Evaluate reviewer reports critically rather than relying solely on a numerical or majority vote.
-
Make decisions based on academic quality and ethical compliance.
-
Provide clear editorial decisions and relevant feedback to authors.
-
Address concerns about reviewer conduct or possible research misconduct.
-
Ensure that accepted manuscripts meet the journal's standards before publication.
Editors must not allow institutional hierarchy, personal relationships, commercial interests, or other inappropriate considerations to influence editorial decisions.
8. Confidentiality and Conflicts of Interest
All manuscripts under review are treated as confidential documents.
Reviewers must not share, reproduce, distribute, or discuss unpublished manuscripts without authorization from the journal.
Editors and reviewers must disclose any financial, professional, personal, or institutional relationships that could affect their impartiality.
When a conflict of interest is identified, the journal will take appropriate measures, including appointing an alternative editor or reviewer.
9. Ethical Concerns During Peer Review
If reviewers or editors identify credible concerns regarding plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, inappropriate authorship, or other forms of misconduct, the matter will be handled in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policies.
The journal may request additional information from the authors, suspend the review process, reject the manuscript, or refer the matter to the relevant institution when warranted.
All concerns will be assessed fairly, with due consideration for the evidence and the rights of the parties involved.
10. Appeals and Complaints
Authors who believe that an editorial decision resulted from a significant procedural error or a misunderstanding of the manuscript may submit a reasoned appeal to the editorial office.
Appeals must provide a clear explanation and supporting evidence. Disagreement with a reviewer's academic opinion alone does not automatically justify reconsideration.
The journal will assess appeals impartially and may seek advice from an independent editor or qualified expert when appropriate.
Complaints concerning reviewer conduct, editorial decisions, or the integrity of the review process will be handled in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policies.
11. Commitment to Fair and Rigorous Peer Review
IQ (Ilmu Al-Qur’an): Jurnal Pendidikan Islam recognizes peer review as a fundamental mechanism for maintaining scholarly quality, academic accountability, and public trust in published research.
The journal is committed to continuously improving its peer-review procedures and aligning them with recognized publication ethics principles, including guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
Further information on publication ethics is available at:
https://publicationethics.org/
Through this process, the journal seeks to publish credible, original, and academically significant contributions to the advancement of Islamic education.
