Plagiarism Policy

Effective: Journal of Islamic Education Management is committed to upholding the highest standards of academic integrity and ethical publishing. The journal strictly prohibits plagiarism in any form and takes all necessary measures to ensure the originality of submitted manuscripts.

Definition of Plagiarism

Plagiarism includes, but is not limited to:

  • Copying text, ideas, data, images, or other materials from another source without proper acknowledgment;

  • Presenting another person's work as one's own;

  • Improper paraphrasing without appropriate citation;

  • Self-plagiarism, including the reuse of substantial portions of previously published work without proper disclosure or citation;

  • Submitting a manuscript that substantially overlaps with previously published or concurrently submitted work.

Any form of plagiarism is considered unethical and unacceptable.

Similarity Check

All submitted manuscripts are screened using plagiarism detection software, including Turnitin or other equivalent similarity-checking tools, before entering the peer-review process.

The journal applies the following similarity threshold:

  • Maximum overall similarity index: 20%

  • Similarity originating from properly cited references, quotations, bibliography sections, standard methodological descriptions, and common academic phrases may be excluded from the assessment at the editor's discretion.

Meeting the similarity threshold does not automatically guarantee acceptance. Editors will evaluate the nature, source, and context of any detected similarities to determine whether they constitute acceptable scholarly practice.

Editorial Actions

Based on the plagiarism screening results, the editorial team may take the following actions:

Similarity Below the Threshold

Manuscripts with an acceptable similarity level and no indication of unethical borrowing may proceed to the editorial and peer-review stages.

Minor Similarity Issues

Authors may be requested to revise the manuscript and improve citations, quotations, or paraphrasing before the review process continues.

Excessive Similarity or Plagiarism

Manuscripts found to contain excessive similarity, unattributed copying, plagiarism, or self-plagiarism may be:

  • Rejected immediately;

  • Returned to the authors for substantial revision;

  • Removed from the review process.

Post-Publication Discovery

If plagiarism is identified after publication, the journal reserves the right to take appropriate actions, including:

  • Publishing a correction notice;

  • Issuing an expression of concern;

  • Retracting the article;

  • Informing the author's institution or relevant authorities when necessary.

Author Responsibility

Authors are fully responsible for ensuring the originality of their submitted work and for properly citing all sources used in the preparation of their manuscripts.

By submitting a manuscript to Effective: Journal of Islamic Education Management, authors confirm that:

  • The manuscript is their original work;

  • All sources have been appropriately acknowledged;

  • The manuscript does not violate copyright laws or intellectual property rights;

  • The manuscript complies with the journal's ethical and plagiarism policies.

The journal is committed to maintaining the integrity of the scholarly record and promoting ethical research and publication practices.