Peer Review Process

Effective: Journal of Islamic Education Management employs a double-blind peer review process to ensure the quality, originality, relevance, and scientific integrity of all published manuscripts. In this process, the identities of both authors and reviewers are concealed throughout the review process.

The review process consists of the following stages:

1. Initial Submission

Authors submit their manuscripts through the journal's online submission system. Submitted manuscripts must comply with the journal's author guidelines, formatting requirements, and publication ethics.

2. Editorial Screening

The Editor-in-Chief or assigned editor conducts an initial evaluation to determine whether the manuscript fits the journal’s focus and scope, meets academic standards, and adheres to ethical requirements. Manuscripts may be rejected at this stage if they are deemed unsuitable or fail to meet basic quality standards.

3. Plagiarism Screening

All manuscripts undergo plagiarism detection using appropriate similarity-checking software. Manuscripts with significant plagiarism, excessive similarity, or unethical citation practices may be rejected immediately.

4. Double-Blind Peer Review

Manuscripts that pass the initial screening are assigned to at least two independent reviewers who possess expertise relevant to the manuscript’s subject area. Reviewers evaluate the manuscript based on:

  • Originality and novelty of the research;
  • Relevance to the field of educational management and Islamic education;
  • Theoretical and methodological rigor;
  • Quality of data analysis and interpretation;
  • Clarity of presentation and organization;
  • Contribution to academic knowledge and professional practice;
  • Adequacy and relevance of references.

5. Review Recommendations

Based on the reviewers’ reports, one of the following recommendations may be made:

  • Accept without revisions
  • Accept with minor revisions
  • Accept with major revisions
  • Resubmit for further review
  • Reject

6. Author Revisions

Authors are required to revise their manuscripts in accordance with the reviewers’ and editors’ comments. Revised manuscripts should be accompanied by a response letter explaining how each comment has been addressed.

7. Editorial Decision

The editor evaluates the revised manuscript and reviewers’ recommendations before making the final publication decision. When necessary, revised manuscripts may be returned to reviewers for additional evaluation.

8. Copyediting and Proofreading

Accepted manuscripts undergo copyediting, language editing, formatting, and proofreading to ensure clarity, consistency, and adherence to the journal’s publication standards.

9. Publication

After completing the editorial and production processes, the manuscript is scheduled for publication in the upcoming issue of the journal and made available online.

Review Timeline

The journal aims to complete the review process efficiently. The average timeline is:

  • Initial editorial screening: 1–2 weeks
  • Peer review process: 4–8 weeks
  • Revision period: 1–4 weeks (depending on the extent of revisions required)
  • Final editorial decision: 1–2 weeks

The total review and publication process may vary depending on manuscript quality, reviewer availability, and the responsiveness of authors.

Confidentiality

All manuscripts submitted to the journal are treated as confidential documents. Editors and reviewers must not disclose any information regarding submitted manuscripts except as necessary for the review and publication process.

Conflict of Interest

Editors and reviewers must disclose any potential conflicts of interest and recuse themselves from handling manuscripts where such conflicts could compromise objectivity and impartiality.

Ethical Review Standards

Reviewers are expected to provide constructive, objective, and evidence-based feedback. Personal criticism of authors is inappropriate, and all evaluations should focus solely on the scholarly merits of the manuscript.