| MAIN MENU |
| Home |
| Current Issue |
| Archives |
| ABOUT THE JOURNAL |
| About the Journal |
| Focus and Scope |
| Editorial Team |
| Contact |
| POLICIES |
| Open Access Policy |
| Copyright Notice |
| Plagiarism Policy |
| Publication Ethics |
| Privacy Statement |
| Advertising and Marketing Policy |
| Revenue Sources |
| AUTHORS |
| Submissions |
| Author Fees |
| Peer Review Process |
| OUR COMMITMENT |
Double-blind peer review. Immediate open access. Authors retain copyright. Published twice a year. |
Peer Review Process
Peer Review Process
Atsar: Journal of Hadith and Contemporary Studies applies a rigorous peer review process to ensure the quality, originality, validity, and scholarly contribution of every manuscript published in the journal. The review process is conducted through a double-blind peer review system, in which the identities of both authors and reviewers are kept confidential.
All submitted manuscripts are evaluated by experts in the relevant field, particularly in Hadith studies, Islamic scholarship, and contemporary studies. The evaluation focuses on the manuscript’s relevance to the journal’s focus and scope, originality, methodological soundness, clarity of argument, contribution to knowledge, and compliance with academic and ethical standards.
1. Preliminary Assessment
After submission, the editorial team conducts an initial assessment of the manuscript. This stage aims to ensure that the manuscript is relevant to the focus and scope of Atsar: Journal of Hadith and Contemporary Studies and complies with the journal’s author guidelines, template, citation style, and publication ethics.
Manuscripts that do not meet the basic requirements may be returned to the authors for correction before further review. Manuscripts that are outside the journal’s scope, lack academic quality, or show indications of plagiarism or excessive similarity may be rejected at this stage.
2. Selection of Reviewers
Manuscripts that pass the preliminary assessment are assigned to independent reviewers with expertise relevant to the topic of the manuscript. The editorial board ensures that reviewers have appropriate scholarly competence and no conflict of interest with the authors or the manuscript under review.
The journal normally assigns at least two reviewers for each manuscript. Reviewers are selected based on their academic background, research expertise, publication record, and relevance to the manuscript’s subject area.
3. Review Process
Reviewers evaluate the manuscript based on several criteria, including originality, relevance, theoretical framework, research method, data analysis, argumentation, contribution to Hadith studies and contemporary scholarship, language clarity, and reference quality.
Reviewers provide constructive comments and recommendations to help authors improve the manuscript. The recommendation may include one of the following decisions:
- Accepted without revision;
- Accepted with minor revision;
- Accepted with major revision;
- Resubmission for review;
- Rejected.
4. Editorial Decision
The editor-in-chief or assigned editor makes the editorial decision based on the reviewers’ comments, recommendations, and the manuscript’s compliance with the journal’s standards. If the reviewers provide significantly different recommendations, the editor may invite an additional reviewer or make a decision based on editorial judgment.
The editorial decision, along with anonymous reviewer comments, will be communicated to the author through the journal system or official communication channel.
5. Revision Stage
Authors whose manuscripts require revision must revise the manuscript according to the reviewers’ and editor’s comments. Authors should submit the revised manuscript together with a response letter explaining how each comment has been addressed.
For minor revisions, authors are usually expected to submit the revised manuscript within two weeks. For major revisions, authors are usually expected to submit the revised manuscript within four weeks. Revised manuscripts may be sent back to the reviewers for further evaluation when necessary.
6. Final Decision and Publication
After the revised manuscript has been evaluated and approved, the editor makes the final decision. Accepted manuscripts will proceed to the copyediting, layout editing, proofreading, and publication stages.
The editorial team may request authors to review the final proof before publication. Authors are responsible for ensuring the accuracy of names, affiliations, citations, references, data, and all other information in the final version of the manuscript.
Peer Review Principles
Atsar: Journal of Hadith and Contemporary Studies is committed to maintaining an objective, fair, confidential, and transparent peer review process. Reviewers are expected to provide constructive, unbiased, and academically responsible evaluations. Authors are expected to respond to reviewer comments respectfully and revise their manuscripts in accordance with scholarly standards.
Through this peer review process, Atsar: Journal of Hadith and Contemporary Studies ensures that all published articles meet the standards of academic integrity, methodological rigor, and scholarly contribution in the field of Hadith and contemporary studies.