Peer Review Process

Editorial Procedures and Peer-Review Process

Initial Checks

All manuscripts submitted to Al-Dhikra: Jurnal Studi Quran dan Hadis will undergo an initial screening by the Managing Editor to ensure that the submission complies with the journal’s author guidelines, ethical standards, and publication policies. Manuscripts that do not conform to the journal’s scope, formatting requirements, or ethical principles will be rejected before to the peer-review process. Manuscripts requiring technical corrections will be returned to the authors for revision and resubmission.

After the preliminary assessment, the Managing Editor, in consultation with the Editor-in-Chief or assigned Editors, will evaluate whether the manuscript fits the focus and scope of the journal and demonstrates sufficient academic quality. At this stage, no judgment regarding the potential impact of the work will be made. Decisions to reject a manuscript during the initial screening process must be verified by the Editor-in-Chief.

Authors will receive an acknowledgment of submission within 12–24 hours after the manuscript is received.


Peer-Review Process

Manuscripts that pass the initial screening will be assigned to at least two independent reviewers with expertise relevant to the subject matter. Al-Dhikra: Jurnal Studi Quran dan Hadis implements a double-blind peer-review system in which both authors’ and reviewers’ identities remain anonymous throughout the review process.

Reviewers are selected by the Editors based on their expertise in Qur’anic studies, Hadith studies, Islamic thought, or related interdisciplinary fields. Members of the Editorial Board may also serve as reviewers when appropriate. All reviewers are expected to uphold the principles of objectivity, confidentiality, and academic integrity.

Reviewers must avoid any conflict of interest. The following situations are considered conflicts of interest:

  1. Reviewers have published with any of the authors within the last three years.
  2. Reviewers currently work or collaborate with the authors’ institutions.
  3. Reviewers are supervising or have supervised the doctoral work of the author(s), or vice versa.
  4. Reviewers may receive professional or personal benefits resulting from the review process.
  5. Reviewers have close personal relationships with the author(s).
  6. Reviewers have direct or indirect financial interests related to the manuscript under review.

Participation in collaborative academic projects or co-organization of scholarly events is not automatically considered a conflict of interest.

The peer-review process generally takes a maximum of six (6) weeks.


Editorial Decision and Revision

All articles published in Al-Dhikra: Jurnal Studi Quran dan Hadis undergo a rigorous peer-review process and receive evaluations from at least two reviewers. Based on the reviewers’ reports, the Editor will communicate one of the following decisions to the authors:

Accept Submission

The manuscript meets the journal’s academic and publication standards and is accepted for publication. The accepted manuscript proceeds to copyediting and production.

Minor Revisions Required

The manuscript is acceptable pending minor revisions based on reviewers’ comments. Authors are given one week to submit the revised version.

Major Revisions / Resubmit for Review

The manuscript requires substantial revisions before it can be reconsidered for publication. Authors must provide a detailed point-by-point response to the reviewers’ comments. Revised manuscripts may be returned to the reviewers for further evaluation. Authors are given a maximum of three weeks to complete major revisions.

Decline Submission

The manuscript contains significant weaknesses, lacks originality, or does not make a substantial scholarly contribution to the field. Rejected manuscripts will not be reconsidered unless explicitly invited for resubmission.

If reviewers recommend additional research or evidence to support the manuscript’s conclusions, the manuscript may be rejected with the suggestion that the authors conduct further research before submitting a new version.

Authors must address all reviewer comments carefully and provide clear justifications for any suggestions they choose not to implement.


Author Appeals

Authors may appeal editorial decisions by submitting a formal appeal via e-mail to the Managing Editor. Appeals must include a detailed explanation and point-by-point responses to the reviewers’ and/or Editors’ comments.

The appeal will be reviewed by the Editor-in-Chief and, when necessary, by members of the Editorial Board or additional reviewers. The reviewing editor may recommend acceptance, additional peer review, or uphold the original rejection decision. Decisions made at this stage are final.


Production and Publication

Accepted manuscripts will undergo professional copyediting, language editing, proofreading, layout editing, and final author corrections before publication. The final version of the article will be published online on the Al-Dhikra: Jurnal Studi Quran dan Hadis website. Print publication, if applicable, will follow within one to two weeks after online publication.


Correcting the Record

Authors may request corrections to published articles in cases involving significant errors affecting the accuracy or integrity of the publication. Requests for correction should be submitted within one week after online publication. Further information regarding corrections, retractions, and updates can be found in the journal’s publication ethics and correction policy